Falling Slinky Lab
Let go of the top.
Watch the bottom.
A stretched spring hangs from a clamp. Open the clamp and the top drops at once, while the bottom stays where it is.
Release it, slow it down, and find out what the bottom is waiting for.
This experiment needs WebGL, which is not available in this browser. The explanation and sources below remain readable.
What is computed. Every coil position comes from a spring model solved as you watch: each coil feels gravity, the pull of the spring on either side of it, and the push of any coil it touches. The top coil is also held by the clamp until release, and the bottom coil has a neighbor only above it. There is no other force until the spring reaches the floor. Springs are drawn to scale, with the measured number of turns and closed length; the coil is drawn 70 mm across, a typical size for these toys, since the published measurements do not give it. An open coil is never drawn thinner than one screen pixel, so it stays visible. Air resistance, twisting and sideways sway are left out.
What to notice
Gravity never lets go.
The tension does, late.
Before release every coil is balanced. The spring above a coil pulls it up, the spring below pulls it down, and the upward pull is larger by exactly that coil's weight. Put another way, the stretch at any height holds up the weight of everything below it, and the clamp holds up the whole spring. Opening the clamp removes the support at the top only. The top coils crash together, and that collapse moves down the spring coil by coil.
Below the collapse the spring is exactly as stretched as before, so those coils are still balanced. Gravity acts on the bottom the whole time. What has not arrived yet is the change in tension.
- Turn on Tension, then release. The bars above the collapse vanish. The bars below it do not change until it arrives.
- Double the stiffness. The spring hangs shorter and the bottom waits less.
- Halve the mass. It also waits less. Heavier and softer springs wait longer.
- Turn on Center of mass. It falls level with a dropped ball from the first instant, even while the bottom has not moved.
- Raise the stiffness until the spring barely stretches. Now there is almost nothing to wait for.
The reasoning, in the open
Look under the model.
Why the center of mass falls freely
The coils push and pull on one another, but every such force comes in an equal and opposite pair, so the pairs cancel when the forces on the whole spring are added. Once the clamp is open the only outside force is gravity. The center of mass therefore accelerates downward at g from the instant of release, even though the bottom coil is still at rest. In this model that holds until the spring reaches the floor; the marker is computed from the mass of every coil, not from the middle of the spring, so it sits below the midpoint where the coils are crowded.
Model and limits
The spring is a chain of lumped turns, one per coil, each carrying an equal share of the mass. Neighboring turns are joined by a tension spring. Turns cannot pass through each other; when they touch they collide without bouncing and then move together. A tightly wound spring also has a minimum tension: neighboring coils stay pressed together until the pull exceeds it, which is why the lowest coils of the metal spring hang closed.
This is the lumped form of the tension-spring model of Calkin (1993) and Cross and Wheatland (2012). For their metal spring (215.5 g, 86 turns, 58 mm when closed, stiffness 0.69 N/m) the model's bottom coil starts to move 0.271 s after release; they report 0.27 s from high-speed video. For their plastic spring the model gives 0.272 s against 0.27 s. The preset stiffness and minimum tension are their fitted values. Validation record · Read the numerical model
The wait is not a universal constant. It depends on the mass, the stiffness and how much of the spring is stretched, and a spring that does not stretch under its own weight does not wait at all. In the model the bottom is still to within a millionth of a millimeter until the collapse arrives; a real spring also twists and trembles slightly, and its coils take a finite time to close. The coil diameter and wire thickness on screen are illustrative and do not enter the motion. Time advances in steps of 0.1 ms or less.
Sources
- R. C. Cross and M. S. Wheatland, "Modeling a falling slinky", American Journal of Physics 80, 1051 (2012)Model, measured spring properties and collapse times. Preprint: arXiv:1208.4629.
- M. G. Calkin, "Motion of a falling spring", American Journal of Physics 61, 261 to 264 (1993)The original collapse-front analysis.
- M. S. Wheatland, "The falling slinky", University of SydneyHigh-speed footage and model animations by the authors.
Slinky is a registered trademark of its owner. This page is not affiliated with or endorsed by the trademark owner.
Keyboard, motion and privacy
Use Tab to reach each control. Space or Enter activates a button, the arrow keys move a slider or choose a speed. With focus on the experiment buttons, R releases or resets, P pauses and the full stop key steps forward. Nothing moves until you release the spring. This page makes no external requests and stores nothing.