{
 "title": "Why Spaghetti Keeps Breaking: validation record",
 "author": "Daniel Hashemi",
 "generated": "2026-11-12T21:15:26-05:00",
 "physicsModuleSha256": "ca40ec064a664c057600aab0dbc53749bdbf6e7aade3704669bb846824b4df55",
 "defaults": {
  "L": 0.24,
  "d": 0.0014,
  "E": 3800000000,
  "rho": 1500,
  "sigmaC": 19000000,
  "flaw": 0.05,
  "flawSpacing": 0.0015,
  "lmin": 0.04,
  "gripExcl": 0.02,
  "tCrack": 0.00001,
  "tauD": 5e-7,
  "N": 120,
  "seed": 3,
  "cfl": 0.35
 },
 "pageSegments": 240,
 "pageSummary": "Across 400 numbered strands at the default settings the model gave 3 pieces for <1 %, 4 pieces for 84 %, 5 pieces for 16 %, and never a clean break in two. This agrees with the common observation that two pieces are uncommon, but the exact shares depend on the shortest-piece assumption.",
 "pageDetail": "Measured: the bent shape, its sharpest bend and the end force agree with the exact solution to within 0.11 %. The overshoot came out as 1.466, 1.436, 1.430 at three successively finer resolutions, against 1.428 in theory, with the crest position growing as time to the power 0.502 (theory 0.5). Wave frequencies were within 1.5 % of theory for waves at least 15 segments long. Without damping the total energy stayed constant to 0.011 % over 20 thousandths of a second; with damping it never rose.",
 "check1_staticElastica": {
  "pass": true,
  "tolerance": 0.01,
  "worstRelativeErrorAtN120orMore": 0.001122058160608952,
  "note": "shape, end slope, largest curvature, mid-span deflection and end load against the analytic pinned-pinned elastica (elliptic integrals, mpmath) for ten end shortenings from 1 % to 50 %"
 },
 "check2_releaseOvershoot": {
  "pass": true,
  "reference": {
   "peak": 1.4279444280438793,
   "x": 1.4142135623730951
  },
  "rows": [
   {
    "kappa0_per_m": 1,
    "segments": 1000,
    "nodesAcrossPeak": [
     4,
     10
    ],
    "peakRatioMean": 1.4898,
    "peakRatioMin": 1.226,
    "peakRatioMax": 1.6461,
    "sPeakSquared_over_4piGammaT": 0.898,
    "logLogSlope": 0.6242
   },
   {
    "kappa0_per_m": 1,
    "segments": 2000,
    "nodesAcrossPeak": [
     8,
     20
    ],
    "peakRatioMean": 1.4656,
    "peakRatioMin": 1.4104,
    "peakRatioMax": 1.6098,
    "sPeakSquared_over_4piGammaT": 0.9921,
    "logLogSlope": 0.5011
   },
   {
    "kappa0_per_m": 1,
    "segments": 4000,
    "nodesAcrossPeak": [
     16,
     40
    ],
    "peakRatioMean": 1.4364,
    "peakRatioMin": 1.4279,
    "peakRatioMax": 1.4626,
    "sPeakSquared_over_4piGammaT": 0.9943,
    "logLogSlope": 0.5025
   },
   {
    "kappa0_per_m": 1,
    "segments": 8000,
    "nodesAcrossPeak": [
     32,
     80
    ],
    "peakRatioMean": 1.4302,
    "peakRatioMin": 1.4282,
    "peakRatioMax": 1.4347,
    "sPeakSquared_over_4piGammaT": 1.0003,
    "logLogSlope": 0.502
   },
   {
    "kappa0_per_m": 14.3,
    "segments": 1000,
    "nodesAcrossPeak": [
     4,
     10
    ],
    "peakRatioMean": 1.4898,
    "peakRatioMin": 1.226,
    "peakRatioMax": 1.6461,
    "sPeakSquared_over_4piGammaT": 0.898,
    "logLogSlope": 0.6242
   },
   {
    "kappa0_per_m": 14.3,
    "segments": 2000,
    "nodesAcrossPeak": [
     8,
     20
    ],
    "peakRatioMean": 1.4656,
    "peakRatioMin": 1.4104,
    "peakRatioMax": 1.6098,
    "sPeakSquared_over_4piGammaT": 0.9921,
    "logLogSlope": 0.5011
   },
   {
    "kappa0_per_m": 14.3,
    "segments": 4000,
    "nodesAcrossPeak": [
     16,
     40
    ],
    "peakRatioMean": 1.4364,
    "peakRatioMin": 1.4279,
    "peakRatioMax": 1.4625,
    "sPeakSquared_over_4piGammaT": 0.9943,
    "logLogSlope": 0.5025
   },
   {
    "kappa0_per_m": 14.3,
    "segments": 8000,
    "nodesAcrossPeak": [
     32,
     80
    ],
    "peakRatioMean": 1.4301,
    "peakRatioMin": 1.4281,
    "peakRatioMax": 1.4347,
    "sPeakSquared_over_4piGammaT": 1.0003,
    "logLogSlope": 0.502
   }
  ]
 },
 "check3_dispersion": {
  "pass": true,
  "tolerance": 0.02,
  "worstErrorAt15NodesPerWavelengthOrMore": 0.014531780805499217,
  "rows": [
   {
    "N": 120,
    "n": 1,
    "nodesPerWavelength": 240,
    "fTheory": 15.191882989739844,
    "fMeasured": 15.191015984510962,
    "err": -0.000057070294016026146
   },
   {
    "N": 120,
    "n": 2,
    "nodesPerWavelength": 120,
    "fTheory": 60.767531958959374,
    "fMeasured": 60.75365083142123,
    "err": -0.0002284300035011455
   },
   {
    "N": 120,
    "n": 3,
    "nodesPerWavelength": 80,
    "fTheory": 136.7269469076586,
    "fMeasured": 136.65667945973726,
    "err": -0.0005139253783585929
   },
   {
    "N": 120,
    "n": 4,
    "nodesPerWavelength": 60,
    "fTheory": 243.0701278358375,
    "fMeasured": 242.84808405730323,
    "err": -0.000913496777704581
   },
   {
    "N": 120,
    "n": 6,
    "nodesPerWavelength": 40,
    "fTheory": 546.9077876306344,
    "fMeasured": 545.78423044441,
    "err": -0.002054381399635763
   },
   {
    "N": 120,
    "n": 8,
    "nodesPerWavelength": 30,
    "fTheory": 972.28051134335,
    "fMeasured": 968.7319108609715,
    "err": -0.003649770247349249
   },
   {
    "N": 120,
    "n": 12,
    "nodesPerWavelength": 20,
    "fTheory": 2187.6311505225376,
    "fMeasured": 2169.7009448973604,
    "err": -0.008196174030934755
   },
   {
    "N": 120,
    "n": 16,
    "nodesPerWavelength": 15,
    "fTheory": 3889.1220453734,
    "fMeasured": 3832.6061762841987,
    "err": -0.014531780805499217
   },
   {
    "N": 120,
    "n": 24,
    "nodesPerWavelength": 10,
    "fTheory": 8750.52460209015,
    "fMeasured": 8466.598798760107,
    "err": -0.032446717910172285
   },
   {
    "N": 240,
    "n": 1,
    "nodesPerWavelength": 480,
    "fTheory": 15.191882989739844,
    "fMeasured": 15.191666736267992,
    "err": -0.000014234803677570795
   },
   {
    "N": 240,
    "n": 2,
    "nodesPerWavelength": 240,
    "fTheory": 60.767531958959374,
    "fMeasured": 60.7640619414474,
    "err": -0.00005710315031903779
   },
   {
    "N": 240,
    "n": 3,
    "nodesPerWavelength": 160,
    "fTheory": 136.7269469076586,
    "fMeasured": 136.70937783827938,
    "err": -0.00012849748916765602
   },
   {
    "N": 240,
    "n": 4,
    "nodesPerWavelength": 120,
    "fTheory": 243.0701278358375,
    "fMeasured": 243.0146021750729,
    "err": -0.00022843473716394058
   },
   {
    "N": 240,
    "n": 6,
    "nodesPerWavelength": 80,
    "fTheory": 546.9077876306344,
    "fMeasured": 546.6267255733422,
    "err": -0.0005139112363160558
   },
   {
    "N": 240,
    "n": 8,
    "nodesPerWavelength": 60,
    "fTheory": 972.28051134335,
    "fMeasured": 971.392388902509,
    "err": -0.0009134426027052056
   },
   {
    "N": 240,
    "n": 12,
    "nodesPerWavelength": 40,
    "fTheory": 2187.6311505225376,
    "fMeasured": 2183.137540469403,
    "err": -0.00205409858607164
   },
   {
    "N": 240,
    "n": 16,
    "nodesPerWavelength": 30,
    "fTheory": 3889.1220453734,
    "fMeasured": 3874.9311123186794,
    "err": -0.0036488783044499318
   },
   {
    "N": 240,
    "n": 24,
    "nodesPerWavelength": 20,
    "fTheory": 8750.52460209015,
    "fMeasured": 8678.842778630013,
    "err": -0.008191717264930176
   }
  ]
 },
 "check4_energy": {
  "pass": true,
  "results": {
   "120": {
    "a": {
     "label": "a",
     "N": 120,
     "dt": 4.3979660370628023e-7,
     "steps": 45476,
     "E0": 0.006703333477058876,
     "Eend": 0.0067030210439013626,
     "maxDev": 0.00006878102569063405,
     "maxRise": 0.000004897330784870158,
     "pieces": 2,
     "kineticEnd": 0.004752246951640226,
     "bendingEnd": 0.0018470693736250656,
     "stretchingEnd": 0.00010370471863607144
    },
    "b": {
     "label": "b",
     "N": 120,
     "dt": 4.3979660370628023e-7,
     "steps": 45476,
     "E0": 0.006611345247005684,
     "Eend": 0.006611350757150063,
     "maxDev": 0.000014105343693948669,
     "maxRise": 0.0000017869136170729424,
     "pieces": 2,
     "kineticEnd": 0.004703362504249458,
     "bendingEnd": 0.0017813331412337276,
     "stretchingEnd": 0.00012665511166687758
    },
    "c": {
     "label": "c",
     "N": 120,
     "dt": 4.3979660370628023e-7,
     "steps": 45476,
     "E0": 0.0066028961136705535,
     "Eend": 0.005510793271115313,
     "maxDev": 0.16539755037099013,
     "maxRise": 0,
     "pieces": 2,
     "kineticEnd": 0.004138190783504441,
     "bendingEnd": 0.001298455817675482,
     "stretchingEnd": 0.0000741466699353902
    }
   },
   "240": {
    "a": {
     "label": "a",
     "N": 240,
     "dt": 2.1989830185314012e-7,
     "steps": 90952,
     "E0": 0.006458434400311566,
     "Eend": 0.006457914469198045,
     "maxDev": 0.00011424066813214839,
     "maxRise": 0.000017954014708282838,
     "pieces": 2,
     "kineticEnd": 0.003176018325631817,
     "bendingEnd": 0.003233912336260444,
     "stretchingEnd": 0.00004798380730578422
    },
    "b": {
     "label": "b",
     "N": 240,
     "dt": 2.1989830185314012e-7,
     "steps": 90952,
     "E0": 0.0063230731839406884,
     "Eend": 0.006323074006184243,
     "maxDev": 0.000004724196132510627,
     "maxRise": 0.0000010271716181755864,
     "pieces": 2,
     "kineticEnd": 0.0031363537265532986,
     "bendingEnd": 0.0031367564679524993,
     "stretchingEnd": 0.000049963811678444694
    },
    "c": {
     "label": "c",
     "N": 240,
     "dt": 2.1989830185314012e-7,
     "steps": 90952,
     "E0": 0.0063127653186353305,
     "Eend": 0.005292667723885581,
     "maxDev": 0.16159282711467415,
     "maxRise": 0,
     "pieces": 2,
     "kineticEnd": 0.002480793588482857,
     "bendingEnd": 0.002791053846489987,
     "stretchingEnd": 0.000020820288912736783
    }
   }
  }
 },
 "check5_pieceStatistics": {
  "default_N120": {
   "label": "default settings, N = 120",
   "seeds": 400,
   "pieceCounts": {
    "3": 1,
    "4": 303,
    "5": 96
   },
   "meanPieces": 4.24,
   "percentExactlyTwo": 0,
   "percentThreeOrMore": 100,
   "latestCrack_ms": 2.86
  },
  "default_N240": {
   "label": "default settings, N = 240 (node count doubled)",
   "seeds": 400,
   "pieceCounts": {
    "3": 1,
    "4": 336,
    "5": 63
   },
   "meanPieces": 4.16,
   "percentExactlyTwo": 0,
   "percentThreeOrMore": 100,
   "latestCrack_ms": 0.55
  },
  "default_N480": {
   "label": "default settings, N = 480 (node count quadrupled)",
   "seeds": 120,
   "pieceCounts": {
    "3": 1,
    "4": 96,
    "5": 23
   },
   "meanPieces": 4.18,
   "percentExactlyTwo": 0,
   "percentThreeOrMore": 100,
   "latestCrack_ms": 0.54
  },
  "default_N60": {
   "label": "default settings, N = 60 (node count halved)",
   "seeds": 400,
   "pieceCounts": {
    "4": 100,
    "5": 300
   },
   "meanPieces": 4.75,
   "percentExactlyTwo": 0,
   "percentThreeOrMore": 100,
   "latestCrack_ms": 3.15
  },
  "lmin30": {
   "label": "minimum piece length 30 mm, N = 120",
   "seeds": 200,
   "pieceCounts": {
    "4": 32,
    "5": 153,
    "6": 15
   },
   "meanPieces": 4.92,
   "percentExactlyTwo": 0,
   "percentThreeOrMore": 100,
   "latestCrack_ms": 13.07
  },
  "lmin30_N240": {
   "label": "minimum piece length 30 mm, N = 240",
   "seeds": 200,
   "pieceCounts": {
    "4": 34,
    "5": 162,
    "6": 4
   },
   "meanPieces": 4.85,
   "percentExactlyTwo": 0,
   "percentThreeOrMore": 100,
   "latestCrack_ms": 12.78
  },
  "lmin50": {
   "label": "minimum piece length 50 mm, N = 120",
   "seeds": 200,
   "pieceCounts": {
    "3": 12,
    "4": 188
   },
   "meanPieces": 3.94,
   "percentExactlyTwo": 0,
   "percentThreeOrMore": 100,
   "latestCrack_ms": 0.45
  },
  "undamped": {
   "label": "no internal damping, N = 120",
   "seeds": 200,
   "pieceCounts": {
    "4": 2,
    "5": 185,
    "6": 13
   },
   "meanPieces": 5.05,
   "percentExactlyTwo": 0,
   "percentThreeOrMore": 100,
   "latestCrack_ms": 2.41
  },
  "flaw02": {
   "label": "strength scatter 2 %, N = 120",
   "seeds": 200,
   "pieceCounts": {
    "4": 162,
    "5": 38
   },
   "meanPieces": 4.19,
   "percentExactlyTwo": 0,
   "percentThreeOrMore": 100,
   "latestCrack_ms": 2.74
  },
  "flaw10": {
   "label": "strength scatter 10 %, N = 120",
   "seeds": 200,
   "pieceCounts": {
    "2": 1,
    "3": 12,
    "4": 150,
    "5": 37
   },
   "meanPieces": 4.12,
   "percentExactlyTwo": 0.5,
   "percentThreeOrMore": 99.5,
   "latestCrack_ms": 3.55
  },
  "instant": {
   "label": "instantaneous crack (tCrack = 0), N = 120",
   "seeds": 200,
   "pieceCounts": {
    "3": 1,
    "4": 153,
    "5": 46
   },
   "meanPieces": 4.22,
   "percentExactlyTwo": 0,
   "percentThreeOrMore": 100,
   "latestCrack_ms": 2.84
  },
  "d10": {
   "label": "diameter 1.0 mm, N = 120",
   "seeds": 100,
   "pieceCounts": {
    "3": 1,
    "4": 84,
    "5": 15
   },
   "meanPieces": 4.14,
   "percentExactlyTwo": 0,
   "percentThreeOrMore": 100,
   "latestCrack_ms": 3.83
  },
  "d20": {
   "label": "diameter 2.0 mm, N = 120",
   "seeds": 100,
   "pieceCounts": {
    "3": 1,
    "4": 75,
    "5": 24
   },
   "meanPieces": 4.23,
   "percentExactlyTwo": 0,
   "percentThreeOrMore": 100,
   "latestCrack_ms": 1.93
  },
  "L20": {
   "label": "length 20 cm, N = 120",
   "seeds": 100,
   "pieceCounts": {
    "3": 2,
    "4": 98
   },
   "meanPieces": 3.98,
   "percentExactlyTwo": 0,
   "percentThreeOrMore": 100,
   "latestCrack_ms": 2.25
  },
  "L28": {
   "label": "length 28 cm, N = 120",
   "seeds": 100,
   "pieceCounts": {
    "4": 61,
    "5": 39
   },
   "meanPieces": 4.39,
   "percentExactlyTwo": 0,
   "percentThreeOrMore": 100,
   "latestCrack_ms": 3.84
  }
 },
 "check5_sameCountSeedBySeed_N120_vs_N240": "335 of 400",
 "limits": "Planar rod, no twist, quasi-static loading, idealised flaws, minimum piece length imposed, no air resistance, no contact between pieces. Not a validated prediction of any particular strand."
}