THEORYMERIDIAN

Quantum Spin Lab · Bosons and fermions

Why can photons
crowd into one state?

Identical bosons can share a quantum state, in any number. Identical fermions, like electrons, cannot share one complete state: the same spatial state and the same spin.Fill the levels and see who fits where.

Ideal quantum model
01 / Fill the states
Allowed stateParticle placedForbidden: amplitude for double occupancy = 0

Ideal, non-interacting particlesFour single-particle levels with energies 1, 4, 9 and 16 E₁. The rack is a picture of the energy ladder: shelf heights follow the energies, and nothing here is a physical shelf. Arrows ↑ and ↓ label spin states, not spinning balls.

Total energy

0E₁

No particles yet.

Start here

Bosons: put as many as you like in any level.

01Choose the particles

Changing the particle type empties the levels.

02Place one particle

Spin labels apply to fermions. These bosons have spin 0.

Nothing forbids ideal bosons from all sharing the lowest level. Fermions must stack up, two per level, so their total energy is higher.

The refusal is not a collision or a force. For identical fermions the quantum amplitude for two of them in one complete state is exactly zero, so that arrangement does not exist.

Where the rule comes from

Swap two identical particles
and watch the sign.

Two particles in a box, one in state a and one in state b. The map shows where you might find them together: particle 1 at x₁ across, particle 2 at x₂ up. Identical particles have no name tags, so swapping their complete labels can only leave the amplitude the same (bosons) or flip its sign (fermions).

Exact two-particle amplitudes
02 / Swap the complete labels (position and spin together)

One-dimensional box, ideal statesThe dashed diagonal is x₁ = x₂: both particles at the same place.

Found within a tenth of the box of each other
0
Same, without exchange effects
0
Swapping the labels gives
+ψ
01Which particles?
02Single-particle states a and b

Choose the same level for a and b to try putting both in one spatial state.

03Show

Spin decides which

Half-integer spin: fermion.
Whole-number spin: boson.

This link between spin and statistics is a theorem of relativistic quantum field theory for particles in three dimensions. The sign picture above illustrates it; it is not a proof.

Classification

Who is which

Fermions (spin ½, 3/2, …)Bosons (spin 0, 1, 2, …)
Electron, quarks, proton, neutronPhoton, gluon, W, Z, Higgs
Helium-3 atom (composite)Helium-4 atom (composite)
Real experiment

Lasers: many photons, one mode

In a laser, very many photons occupy the same mode of the light field. Dubin and colleagues even ran a laser on a single trapped ion.

Real lasers may run on one mode or several, and the number of photons in a mode is not fixed. Filling one level, as above, is not a model of a laser. F. Dubin et al., Quantum to classical transition in a single-ion laser, Nature Physics 6, 350 (2010).

Consequence

Two electrons per orbital

An orbital is a spatial state, not a planetary orbit. It can hold two electrons, one with each spin, because their complete states differ. A p subshell, with three orbitals, holds six.

This is why electrons in atoms fill shells instead of all dropping to the lowest one.

The reasoning, in the open

Look under the model.

The calculation

Each particle can be in one of four states of a one-dimensional box of width 1: φₙ(x) = √2 sin(nπx), with energy n² E₁. For two identical particles in states a and b:

bosons: ψ(x₁, x₂) = [φa(x₁)φb(x₂) + φb(x₁)φa(x₂)] / √2
fermions, same spin: ψ(x₁, x₂) = [φa(x₁)φb(x₂) − φb(x₁)φa(x₂)] / √2

If a = b the fermion amplitude is zero everywhere: there is no such state. For bosons with a = b the state is φa(x₁)φa(x₂). For fermions with opposite spins the complete states differ even when a = b. Summed over spins, the position probability is [|φa(x₁)φb(x₂)|² + |φb(x₁)φa(x₂)|²] / 2, with no exchange term.

The readout integrates the probability over |x₁ − x₂| < 0.1 on a 240 × 240 grid. Fermion occupation of a complete state is 0 or 1; boson occupation is 0, 1, 2, …

Read the numerical model · Validation record

Sources
Limits of this model

The particles do not interact. The exchange sign is not a repulsive force, and the forbidden arrangement is not an annihilation. Bosons may share a state but do not have to; at nonzero temperature they spread over many states. The bosons here have spin 0, so they carry no spin label.

Keyboard, motion and privacy

Use Tab to reach each control, arrow keys within each group of choices, and Enter or Space for buttons. Pause freezes the swap animation only. Motion starts paused when your system asks for reduced motion. Results are written as text. The page runs entirely in your browser with no accounts, trackers or external code. See the privacy notice.