THEORYMERIDIAN

Charge, Fields & Light Lab · Electrical signals

Why does a lamp respond before
electrons travel around the circuit?

A battery, a switch, three metres of cable and a lamp. The lamp responds 15 billionths of a second after the switch closes. An electron leaving the switch would need days to reach it.Press play, then change the lamp's resistance.

Ideal model · lossless cable, fixed resistances
10 / Battery, cable, lamp
Voltage along the cable now; lamp voltage so farFinal steady valueElectron drift markers (hugely exaggerated)

Computed from the model · two different time scales

The lamp first responds after

15.0ns

Start here: play, and watch the step reach the lamp

In nanoseconds.

The cable behaves like 50 Ω to a travelling step. A lamp of 50 Ω absorbs the step completely; any other value sends part of it back.

A real battery has some. It decides how much of an echo is sent back again.

In metres.

Three speeds, three things. The signal, a change in the fields around the wires, travels along the cable at about two thirds of the speed of light. The energy travels with it, in those fields. The electrons, which are already everywhere in the wire, start to drift when the signal reaches them, at a fraction of a millimetre per second.

What arrives, and when

The wire was
already full.

A pipe full of water delivers water at the far end as soon as the pressure arrives. The comparison is rough, but the point holds.

Signal

A travelling step

When the switch closes, the voltage does not appear everywhere at once. A step moves down the cable, and behind it current flows. Its speed is set by the insulation between the conductors: about 20 cm per nanosecond in common cable.

The Feynman Lectures on Physics, Vol. II, Ch. 24.

Echoes

Why the lamp's value matters

The step does not yet know what is at the far end. It carries the current the cable itself calls for. If the lamp needs a different current, part of the step is reflected, and the voltage settles after several echoes.

The Feynman Lectures on Physics, Vol. II, Ch. 24.

The reasoning, in the open

Look under the model.

The calculation

An ideal cable of impedance Z₀ = 50 Ω and signal speed v = 2 × 10⁸ m/s. A 12 V battery with internal resistance Rs is connected at t = 0. The first step has height 12 V × Z₀/(Z₀ + Rs). At each end a fraction

Γ = (R − Z₀) / (R + Z₀)

of an arriving step is reflected, with R the resistance at that end. The voltage anywhere is the sum of all steps that have passed that point, and it tends to 12 V × RL/(Rs + RL).

Drift speed: vd = I/(n e A) with n = 8.5 × 10²⁸ m⁻³ and A = 1 mm². For 1 A that is 0.073 mm/s.

Read the numerical model (line.js) · Validation record

Sources
Limits of this model

The cable is ideal: no resistance, no leakage, the same speed at all frequencies. The lamp is a fixed resistance; a real filament changes resistance as it heats and takes milliseconds to glow. The picture is one-dimensional: it does not show the fields between the conductors or what happens in circuits whose wires are far apart, where the arrangement of the wires in space matters. The speed quoted is for this cable; other cables and other materials differ, and there is no single "speed of electricity".

Keyboard, motion and privacy

Use Tab to reach each control, arrow keys for sliders, and Enter or Space for buttons. The time slider and the step buttons do everything that play does. Playback starts paused when your system asks for reduced motion. Results are written as text. The page runs entirely in your browser with no accounts, trackers or external code. See the privacy notice.