THEORYMERIDIAN

Charge, Fields & Light Lab · Electromagnetic signals

Does an electric force
arrive instantly?

Three detectors read the field of one charge, from 30, 60 and 90 cm away. Now nudge the charge. Do all three notice at once?Press play and watch the clock.

Exact field of a point charge on a set path, in vacuum
04 / Charge, detectors, clock
Field at each detector, nowField in space, and the travelling newsIf the force were instant (what-if)

Computed from the model · slowed for viewingOne nanosecond of simulated time is shown in two seconds: about two billion times slower than real. Distances are drawn to scale. Each arrow at a detector is scaled to that detector's own reading before the charge moved.

Simulation clock

0.00nsafter the charge starts to move
DetectorDistanceNews arrivesNow

Start here: play, pause when the first detector reacts, then step

In nanoseconds. Light crosses 30 cm in one nanosecond.

02How the charge moves

A quicker move means harder acceleration and a stronger sideways pulse. That pulse fades as 1/distance, so pulse × distance is nearly the same at all three detectors, while the steady field fades as 1/distance². The charge always stays below the speed of light.

04Show

Only changes travel. Before the nudge, the field at each detector is simply there; nothing is being sent. When the charge moves, the change spreads outward at the speed of light, 29.98 cm every nanosecond. Until it arrives, a detector reads exactly what it read before.

What the experiment shows

Not Coulomb's law,
arriving late.

It is tempting to say the detector feels the ordinary Coulomb force from where the charge used to be. That is right only while the charge has always been at rest.

Theory

The sideways pulse

While the charge accelerates, the field gains a part that points across the line of sight. It falls off as 1/r, more slowly than the 1/r² of a static field, so far away it is the largest thing a detector sees. This is electromagnetic radiation.

The Feynman Lectures on Physics, Vol. I, Ch. 28.

Theory

The steady glide

For a charge moving at constant velocity, the field at a detector points away from where the charge is now, not from where it was when the field set out. The field carries the motion with it. A delayed Coulomb arrow would point in the wrong direction.

The Feynman Lectures on Physics, Vol. II, Ch. 26.

Physical law

Cause before effect

No reading changes before light from the event could reach the detector. In vacuum the limit is c = 299 792 458 m/s. In materials and on wires, signals travel more slowly, and that is a separate story.

The Feynman Lectures on Physics, Vol. II, Ch. 21.

The reasoning, in the open

Look under the model.

The calculation

The field at a detector at time t depends on the charge at the earlier time tr when a signal leaving it at speed c would arrive exactly now:

c (t − tr) = distance from the charge's position at tr to the detector

The page solves this for tr by bisection and then evaluates the Liénard–Wiechert field, the exact solution of Maxwell's equations for a point charge on a given path:

E = q/(4πε₀) [ (n − β)(1 − β²) / (κ³R²) + n × ((n − β) × β′) / (c κ³R) ],   κ = 1 − n·β

n points from the earlier position to the detector, R is that distance, β is the velocity divided by c and β′ the acceleration divided by c, all taken at tr. The first term falls as 1/R². The second exists only while the charge accelerates and falls as 1/R.

The nudge moves the charge by a distance d in a time T along a smooth curve (position, velocity and acceleration all continuous), so nothing in the field comes from an artificial jerk. The charge is 10 nC. Detectors sit at 30, 60 and 90 cm, at right angles to the motion.

Read the numerical model · Validation record

Sources
Limits of this model

One point charge in empty space, moved along a line by something outside the model; the force that moves it and the energy it radiates away are not tracked here. The detectors measure the field without disturbing it. Only the electric field is drawn, although a magnetic field accompanies it. The violet "instant" arrows are a what-if for comparison and do not solve Maxwell's equations. Moving 3 cm in a nanosecond takes speeds near a fifth of the speed of light: chosen so that the delay and the pulse are both visible on one screen, not because a laboratory charge is moved this way.

Keyboard, motion and privacy

Use Tab to reach each control, arrow keys for sliders, and Enter or Space for buttons. The time slider and the step buttons do everything that play does. Playback starts paused when your system asks for reduced motion. Results are written as text. The page runs entirely in your browser with no accounts, trackers or external code. See the privacy notice.